Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
57 lines (43 loc) · 6.36 KB

history_clusters.md

File metadata and controls

57 lines (43 loc) · 6.36 KB

History Clusters Security Analysis

Component Focus: Chromium's History Clustering functionality, specifically the HistoryClustersService class in components/history_clusters/core/history_clusters_service.cc and the OnDeviceClusteringBackend class in components/history_clusters/core/on_device_clustering_backend.cc.

Potential Logic Flaws:

  • Data leakage through cluster grouping: Maliciously crafted history entries could lead to unintended grouping.
  • Cluster manipulation: Attackers might manipulate the clustering algorithm. The interaction between HistoryClustersService and the backend in history_clusters_service.cc needs review.
  • Insufficient data sanitization: Improper sanitization could lead to vulnerabilities. The OnDeviceClusteringBackend in on_device_clustering_backend.cc handles visit data and needs to be reviewed for proper sanitization.
  • Improper handling of filter parameters: The QueryClustersFilterParams structure could be vulnerable. The GetClusters and GetClustersForUI functions in on_device_clustering_backend.cc use these parameters and need review.
  • Concurrency issues: Asynchronous operations could introduce race conditions. The use of background threads in on_device_clustering_backend.cc introduces concurrency risks.
  • Data deserialization vulnerabilities: The KeywordsCacheToDict and DictToKeywordsCache functions could be vulnerable.
  • Algorithm flaws in cluster creation: The CreateInitialClustersFromVisits and ShouldAddVisitToCluster functions could contain flaws. The ClusterVisitsOnBackgroundThread function in on_device_clustering_backend.cc uses the Clusterer and needs review.
  • SQL injection vulnerabilities: The GetAnnotatedVisitsToCluster class could be vulnerable.
  • Race conditions in database interactions: Asynchronous database operations could introduce race conditions.
  • Vulnerabilities in inter-service communication: The OnDeviceClusteringBackend interacts with other services. The ProcessVisits function in on_device_clustering_backend.cc interacts with the OptimizationGuideDecider and needs review.
  • Race conditions in cluster processing: The ProcessVisits and other asynchronous functions could lead to race conditions. The ProcessVisits, GetClustersForUIOnBackgroundThread, and GetClusterTriggerabilityOnBackgroundThread functions in on_device_clustering_backend.cc perform asynchronous operations and need to be reviewed for race conditions.
  • Vulnerabilities related to preference handling: Improper handling of preferences could introduce vulnerabilities.
  • Command-line override file vulnerability: Improper handling of the override file could allow manipulation.
  • Vulnerabilities in utility functions: Utility functions could introduce vulnerabilities.
  • Visit Data Handling: The ProcessVisits function in on_device_clustering_backend.cc needs to be reviewed for proper validation and sanitization of visit data, especially URLs and content annotations, to prevent injection attacks.
  • Cluster Processing and Finalization: The cluster processing and finalization functions in on_device_clustering_backend.cc, including GetClustersForUIOnBackgroundThread and GetClusterTriggerabilityOnBackgroundThread, need to be reviewed for secure handling of cluster data, proper filtering, and prevention of information leakage.

Further Analysis and Potential Issues:

  • Codebase Research: The core logic for history clustering is in history_clusters_service.cc. Key functions include QueryClusters, UpdateClusters, DoesQueryMatchAnyCluster, KeywordsCacheToDict, and DictToKeywordsCache. The CreateInitialClustersFromVisits function in clusterer.cc requires review. The ShouldAddVisitToCluster function also needs analysis. The GetAnnotatedVisitsToCluster class handles database interactions and requires review. The OnDeviceClusteringBackend class handles core clustering logic and requires review. The FileClusteringBackend class needs review. The GetClustersFromFile function is critical. The history_clusters_util.cc file contains utility functions requiring review. Additional files will also be reviewed. Analysis of on_device_clustering_backend.cc reveals potential vulnerabilities related to visit processing, cluster filtering and finalization, optimization guide interaction, engagement score handling, data handling and storage, and concurrency/synchronization.
  • Data Structures: The QueryClustersFilterParams structure requires input validation. The IncompleteVisitContextAnnotations structure needs review.
  • CVE Analysis: This section will list relevant CVEs.

Areas Requiring Further Investigation:

  • Detailed analysis of clustering algorithm implementation.
  • Review of data sanitization and validation.
  • Assessment of race conditions in asynchronous operations.
  • Examination of interactions with other Chromium components.
  • Thorough security review of serialization functions.
  • Thorough review of database query construction.
  • Analysis of inter-service communication for vulnerabilities.
  • Thorough analysis of concurrency control.
  • Input validation for preference operations.
  • Secure handling of the switches::kClustersOverrideFile switch.
  • Thorough security review of utility functions.
  • Engagement Score Usage: The use of engagement scores in the clustering process needs further analysis to ensure that it doesn't introduce biases or vulnerabilities.
  • Synchronization and Thread Safety: The OnDeviceClusteringBackend uses multiple threads and asynchronous operations. The synchronization mechanisms and thread safety of the code need to be thoroughly reviewed to prevent race conditions and data corruption.

Secure Contexts and History Clusters:

This section will discuss how secure contexts affect history clustering.

Privacy Implications:

This section will discuss the privacy implications of history clustering.

Additional Notes:

Files reviewed: components/history_clusters/core/history_clusters_service.cc, components/history_clusters/core/clusterer.cc, components/history_clusters/core/history_clusters_db_tasks.cc, components/history_clusters/core/on_device_clustering_backend.cc, components/history_clusters/core/file_clustering_backend.cc, components/history_clusters/core/history_clusters_util.cc.