Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Debatable entries #13

Open
drdhaval2785 opened this issue Oct 5, 2022 · 18 comments
Open

Debatable entries #13

drdhaval2785 opened this issue Oct 5, 2022 · 18 comments
Labels
question Further information is requested

Comments

@drdhaval2785
Copy link
Contributor

Case 1

06084	123-22	<p> उडु	<p> उडु	<p> उडु	#-n.f.	$--1. A lunar mansion, a star, इंदुप्रकाशांतरितोडुतुल्याः /R./xvi.65; 2. water.	79
06085		<b> -उडुप, -उडूप	<b> उडु-उडुप, उडु-उडूप	<+> उडूडुप, उडूडूप	#-(I) m.n.	$--a raft or float, तितीर्षुर्दुस्तरं मोहादिडुपेनास्मि सागरम् /R./i.2.	70
06086					#-(II) m.	$--the moon.	12

I think the words are उडुप and उडूप only and not उडूडुप, उडूडूप.
What do others say? @Andhrabharati

image

@drdhaval2785
Copy link
Contributor Author

Case 2

Unable to decipher the headword of the first entry.

image

@Andhrabharati
Copy link

I think the words are उडुप and उडूप only and not उडूडुप, उडूडूप.
What do others say? @Andhrabharati

You got the words right, @drdhaval2785 !

As I am looking at your LRV work in the past few days, I understand that my work in those early days (6 years back) of Devanagari treading is not that good; but I guess it had improved over next 2-3 years sufficiently.

@Andhrabharati
Copy link

Andhrabharati commented Oct 5, 2022

Unable to decipher the headword of the first entry.

It is uravya (as per tradition, the vysya is born from the Uru of Brahma).

The index word on the top of the column shows the word clearer, though it is not that clear in the running text below.

@drdhaval2785
Copy link
Contributor Author

It should have been ऊरव्य then. But it is shown as उरव्य

@drdhaval2785
Copy link
Contributor Author

Case 3

A case in which there is clear print error. Entries of ऊर्ध्वक and ऊर्मि are erroneously combined.

See LRV

image

See AP90

image

@Andhrabharati
Copy link

It should have been ऊरव्य then. But it is shown as उरव्य

Right, probably we should take it as a print error.

@Andhrabharati
Copy link

A case in which there is clear print error. Entries of ऊर्ध्वक and ऊर्मि are erroneously combined.

Good catch!!

@drdhaval2785
Copy link
Contributor Author

Case 4

Whether to change from कपित्थास्पद to कपित्थास्य based on other dictionaries?

LRV

image

AP90

image

MW

image

@drdhaval2785
Copy link
Contributor Author

Case 5

10493	211-05	<p> कोला(लि, ली)	<p> कोला(लि, ली)	<p> कोला(लि, ली)	#-f.	$--See बदरी.	12

Not actually a question.
Just noting it here, because it gives errors due to difficulty in parsing.

@drdhaval2785
Copy link
Contributor Author

Case 6

I am unaware about this grammatical rule. Can anyone shed some more light on how गूढ+आत्मन् becomes गूढोत्मन् ?

image

@Andhrabharati
Copy link

Could it be gUDhaH + Atman?

@Andhrabharati
Copy link

The above quote is from SiddhantaKaumudi (1034: 6-3-109).

image

@drdhaval2785
Copy link
Contributor Author

Case 7

27564	528-13	<p> भिष्मटा, भिष्मिका, भिस्सटा, भिस्सिटा	<p> भिष्मटा, भिष्मिका, भिस्सटा, भिस्सिटा	<p> भिष्मटा, भिष्मिका, भिस्सटा, भिस्सिटा	#-f.	$--Parched grain.	17

I am not sure about भिष्मटा.

@Andhrabharati
Copy link

could it be changed as भिष्मिटा, as in Apte?

@gasyoun gasyoun added the question Further information is requested label Oct 6, 2022
@drdhaval2785
Copy link
Contributor Author

Case 8

Entry मंदसान has been erroneously entered inside मंदर by LRV

LRV

image

AP90

image

@drdhaval2785
Copy link
Contributor Author

Case 9

विष्णुरिंगी 681-16
Should it be changed to विष्णुलिंगी to match with all other dictionaries?

@drdhaval2785
Copy link
Contributor Author

drdhaval2785 commented Oct 9, 2022

Case 10

सप्ताश्ववाहन wrongly entered as सप्तात्मवाहन

LRV

image

AP

image

@gasyoun
Copy link
Member

gasyoun commented Jan 5, 2024

@drdhaval2785 corrrected and closable? @Andhrabharati nothing to be added?

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
question Further information is requested
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants