[GSoC] Project6: Push-based Metrics Collection for Katib

[Electronic-Waste]

Goal

The project aims to provide a Python SDK API interface for users to push metrics to Katib DB directly.

The current implementation of Metrics Collector is pull-based, raising design problems such as determining the frequency at which we scrape the metrics, performance issues like the overhead caused by too many sidecar containers, and restrictions on developing environments that must support sidecar containers and admission webhooks.

Thus, we decided to implement a new API for Katib Python SDK to offer users a push-based way to store metrics directly into the Kaitb DB and resolve those issues raised by pull-based metrics collection.

What I did in GSoC Project & Ongoing Works

This issue tracks the progress of developing push-based metrics collection for katib during the GSoC coding phase.

I raised numerous PRs for the Katib and Training-Operator project. Some of them are related to my GSoC project, and others may contribute to the completeness of UTs, simplicity of dependency package, and the compatibility of UI component, etc.

Also, I raised some issues not only to describe the problems and bugs I met during the coding period, but also to suggest the future enhancement direction for Katib and Training-Operator.

PRs concerned with the project:

• Convert GSoC proposal to KEP: [GSoC] KEP for Project 6: Push-based Metrics Collection for Katib #2328
• Add new parameter in tune function: [GSoC] Add New Parameter in tune #2369
• New interface report_metrics in Python SDK: [GSoC] New Interface report_metrics in Python SDK #2371
• Compatibility changes in trial controller: [GSoC] Compatibility Changes in Trial Controller #2394
• Perform unit tests and e2e tests:
• [SDK] fix grpc related bugs in Python SDK #2398
• [SDK] test: Add e2e test for tune function. #2399
• Create documents for the new feature, including API specification, usage, examples, etc.
• doc(katib): update push-based metrics collector. website#3844
• [GSoC] Provide a PyTorch MNIST Example for Push-based Metrics Collection #2437
• [GSoC] Summary for Project 6: Push-based Metrics Collection blog#155

Other PRs:

• fix: remove the dependency of protocmp in google.golang.org/protobuf/testing/protocmp. #2391
• [Test] Refactor inject_webhook_test.go according to the Developer Guide #2401
• [SDK] Add UTs for wait_for_job_conditions training-operator#2196
• fix(ui): update None Collector with Push Collector. #2418

Issues I raised:

• [GSoC] Project6: Push-based Metrics Collection for Katib #2340
• Refactor /pkg/webhook/v1beta1/pod/inject_webhook_test.go according to Developer Guide. #2388
• Remove dependency google.golang.org/protobuf/testing/protocmp #2389
• [Discussion] The future of Trial metadata parameters. #2390
• [SDK] grpc-related bugs in Python SDK #2395
• [SDK] Support More MCKind in tune #2402
• [SDK] Fix the tricky import changes in Python SDK #2416
• [Test] E2e Tests for Notebook Examples #2417
• [SDK] Add Some Checks for metrics Field in report_metrics() Interface #2421
• SDK is broken when installed by git+https #2422
• TypeError: unary_unary() got an unexpected keyword argument '_registered_method' #2427
• [Test] E2e Tests for Notebook Examples training-operator#2246

Please let me know if you have any suggestions @kubeflow/wg-automl-leads !

The Lesson I learned during the Project

1. Think Twice, Code Once: @andreyvelich taught me that we should think of the API specification and all the related details before coding. This can significantly reduce the workload of the coding period and avoid big refactor of the project. Meanwhile, my understanding of Katib got clear gradually during the over-and-over rounds of re-think and re-design of the architecture.

2. Dive into the Source Code: Engineering projects nowadays are extremely complex and need much effort to understand them. The best way to get familiar with the project is to dive into the source code and run several examples.

3. Communication: Communication is the most important thing when we collaborate with others. Expressing your idea precisely and making others understand you easily are significant skills not only in open source community but also in various scenes such as company and group works.

In the End

Special Thanks:

• To my mentors @andreyvelich @johnugeorge @tenzen-y, especially @andreyvelich . Your great knowledge about the code base and the industry impressed me a lot. Thanks for your timely response to my PRs and for always attending the weekly meetings to solve my pending problems. I benefited a lot from your precious guidance.
• To @gaocegege . You recommend me to the Kubeflow Community. Thanks for your patient answers for my endless silly questions.
• To Google. Thanks for offering such a precious opportunity for me to begin my journey in the open source world!

I hold a firm belief that every small step counts, and everybody in the community is unique and of great significance. There is no doubt that our joint efforts will surely contribute to the flourishing of our Kubeflow Community, make it the world-best community managing AI lifecycle on Kubernetes, and attract much more attention from the industry. Then, more and more new comers will pour in and work along with us.

Again, I'll continue to contribute to Kubeflow.

[Electronic-Waste]

/assign
/area gsoc

[github-actions]

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.

[Electronic-Waste]

/remove-lifecycle stale